Ask almost any American whether they are comfortable with how their personal information is handled online and the answer is likely to be a sigh. Surveys over the past several years repeat the same message in different words: people feel their data is vulnerable, they do not understand who holds it and they do not believe they have much control. This guide looks at what the research says, why the worry is not just a feeling, why people often do little despite their concern and what practical steps convert anxiety into action. The figures from 2018 polls remain useful as a benchmark, and more recent data show the trend continuing. For a deeper dive into attitudes, see privacy and sharing attitudes: key findings and tips.
1. What the surveys found
In 2018, a YouGov poll reported that 73% of Americans said they felt their online data and personal information was vulnerable to hackers, and 29% said they paid for computer and data protection services. In the same year, the Pew Research Center found that 64% of Americans reported personally experiencing a major data breach, and sizable shares reported unauthorized credit card charges, notices that sensitive account information was no longer secure and, for a smaller share, misuse of their Social Security number.
Those numbers are several years old. We cite them as a benchmark, not as current statistics. What matters is the consistency: later surveys by various organizations continue to show that most Americans are concerned about how companies use their data, believe they have little control and doubt that companies protect data well. If you want current figures, check the latest releases from reputable research organizations.
2. Why the worry is justified
Breaches are large and frequent
The 2017 Equifax breach exposed data of about 147 million people and showed how much sensitive information a single company can hold. Many large breaches since then have involved retailers, health providers, social platforms and financial institutions. See the Equifax breach, millions still at risk and the worst year for data breaches.
Fraud is common and costly
The Federal Trade Commission received about 3 million fraud reports in 2025, with roughly $15.9 billion in reported losses (ftc.gov). The FBI’s Internet Crime Complaint Center received 1,008,597 complaints with $20.877 billion in reported losses, including 67,456 personal data breach complaints and 31,675 identity theft complaints (ic3.gov).
Data brokers trade in personal information
Brokers compile and sell profiles of people who never dealt with them. See what data brokers are.
Consent is thin
Privacy policies are long, controls are hard to find and defaults favor collection. People can reasonably feel they never agreed to much of what happens.
Curious what’s already out there? Wiperts’ 100% Free Diagnosis shows which data brokers are listing your name, home address and phone number. Check your exposure free — it takes about a minute.
3. The privacy paradox
People say they care about privacy and yet continue to share data. Researchers call this the privacy paradox. It is better understood as a mismatch between preferences and options. The benefits of sharing are immediate and visible, such as free services and convenience. The costs are delayed and invisible, such as a future breach or a scam. Opting out often means giving up a service or spending hours on forms. Meanwhile, people lack clear information about which actions matter most. See is privacy losing out to sharing for more.
This is not a personal failing. It is a design problem, and the solution is to make good choices easy: defaults that protect, tools that automate and clear guidance on a short list of high-impact actions.
4. Turning concern into action
If you are among the majority who feel at risk, five steps deliver most of the benefit.
- Secure accounts. Use a password manager, unique passwords and two-factor authentication.
- Freeze your credit. It is free and blocks new accounts. See what is a credit freeze.
- Limit sharing. Skip optional data, use an alias email and review app permissions.
- Remove public listings. Opt out of people-search sites using official pages such as Spokeo, the PeopleConnect suppression center and That’s Them. California residents can use DROP at privacy.ca.gov/drop; registered brokers began processing on August 1, 2026 and repeat every 45 days.
- Monitor and respond. Review statements, check credit reports and use identitytheft.gov and reportfraud.ftc.gov if something happens.
5. What would make people feel safer
Research and common sense suggest a few changes would help.
- Stronger laws. Clear rights to access, delete and opt out, with enforcement. The California Privacy Protection Agency illustrates one approach.
- Better defaults. Privacy-protective settings turned on by default.
- Simpler controls. One-step opt-outs, such as California’s DROP platform for registered brokers.
- Accountability for breaches. Penalties and obligations that make security a priority.
- Education. Plain-language guidance for families, schools and older adults.
Until those changes arrive everywhere, personal steps fill the gap.
6. Generational differences
Attitudes vary by age. Younger adults share more but also use privacy settings more actively. Older adults tend to share less but face higher fraud losses; the FBI’s Internet Crime Complaint Center received 201,266 complaints from people 60 and older in 2025, with $7.748 billion in reported losses (ic3.gov). Parents worry about children’s data, and employees worry about workplace monitoring. Tailor your approach to your life stage: students focus on social settings, parents on children and family listings, older adults on scams and call blocking.
7. Timeline: from worry to routine
| When | Action |
|---|---|
| Today | Enable two-factor authentication on email |
| This week | Freeze credit, review app permissions |
| This month | Begin broker opt-outs, tighten social settings |
| Each quarter | Re-check listings and statements |
8. Trust in companies and institutions
Surveys also probe trust. Many Americans say they trust banks and health providers more than social networks or advertisers with their data, but few express strong confidence in any sector. Breaches and high-profile misuse have eroded trust, and mixed messaging, such as privacy marketing alongside data-hungry business models, adds to skepticism. Rebuilding trust requires transparency about what is collected, meaningful choices and consistent enforcement. For individuals, the practical lesson is to extend trust cautiously and verify claims, reading what companies actually say in their policies and what regulators say in enforcement actions at ftc.gov.
9. How to read survey statistics sensibly
Statistics about privacy vary with question wording, sample and year. A survey that asks “have you experienced a data breach” may count notifications, while one that asks “have you been a victim of identity theft” counts confirmed misuse. Percentages from 2018 may not reflect today’s environment. When you see a number, ask who ran the survey, who was asked, how the question was phrased and whether the result is current. Treat single statistics with caution, and look for consistent patterns across multiple sources. The pattern here is clear: majorities are worried, and rightly so.
10. What individuals say they want
Across many studies, people ask for similar things: clear explanations in plain language, easy ways to see and delete data, strong default protections, penalties for companies that misuse data and accountability for breaches. These desires align with the direction of recent state laws and regulatory efforts, including California’s platform for deleting data from registered brokers, described at privacy.ca.gov/drop. You can support these shifts by using the tools, giving feedback to companies and contacting elected representatives.
11. Helping others turn concern into action
If you are the person in your family who understands privacy, offer to help. Sit down with a relative for an hour and set up their password manager, enable two-factor authentication, freeze their credit and search their name together. Many people never take these steps because no one has shown them how, not because they do not care. A single session can reduce a relative’s risk dramatically, and it builds a habit of checking in. See 5 tips for protecting your online privacy as a short guide to share.
12. Three scenarios and what to do
Scenario 1: You feel anxious but overwhelmed. Pick one action today and one next week. Progress reduces anxiety.
Scenario 2: Your data was in a major breach. Freeze credit, change passwords and read data breach response strategies.
Scenario 3: You want to help family members. Start with their email security, credit freezes and call-blocking, then remove their listings.
13. Myths and facts
| Myth | Fact |
|---|---|
| Concern is overblown | Data shows frequent breaches and fraud |
| People do not care | They care but lack easy options |
| Nothing can be done | Focused steps reduce risk |
| Only the old are targeted | All ages face risks |
| Paying for protection is required | Many measures are free |
14. Common mistakes
- Doing nothing because the problem feels too large.
- Relying on one measure.
- Ignoring the public exposure layer.
- Not discussing risks with family.
- Waiting for laws to protect you.
15. Questions to ask yourself
What worries me most: money, safety or reputation? What is the single step that addresses it? Who else in my life needs help? When will I do it? Commit to a date.
16. How Wiperts fits
Worry becomes action when the steps are clear. Wiperts takes on the broker-removal step: it scans more than 100 data brokers and people-search sites, submits removal requests, removes personal results from Google and Bing, blurs your home on maps and monitors for returning profiles. Start with the free diagnosis to see your exposure.
100% Free Diagnosis: Check Your Exposure
Find out what data brokers have on you. Enter your details in the free scanner on the Wiperts homepage:
- First Name
- Last Name
- Select State
- Email Address
- Website
Scan Databases Now — no payment is needed to see your exposure report.
17. Key takeaways
- Surveys show most Americans feel their online data is at risk and many have experienced breaches.
- The worry is supported by breach history, fraud statistics and broker data sales.
- The privacy paradox reflects hard-to-use controls, not indifference.
- Secure accounts, freeze credit, limit sharing, remove listings and monitor.
Pick the Wiperts plan that fits your household
| Plan | Covers | One-time deep scrub | Then |
|---|---|---|---|
| Individual | 1 person | $89 | $14/month |
| Couples (most popular) | 2 people | $149 | $24/month |
| Family | Up to 4 people | $199 | $39/month |
Every plan includes removal of your name, date of birth, salary, home address and phone number from 100+ data brokers and people-search sites, Google and Bing search-result removal, home blurring on maps, and 24/7 monitoring that re-removes your data if it reappears. See plans and start your removal
18. Frequently Asked Questions
Do most Americans worry about online privacy?
Surveys over many years consistently find that majorities feel their personal information online is vulnerable and want more control.
How many Americans have experienced a data breach?
A 2018 Pew Research survey found that 64% reported experiencing a major data breach, and later surveys continue to show high exposure.
Was the Equifax breach a factor in these concerns?
Yes. The 2017 breach exposed data for about 147 million people and became a symbol of how much sensitive information credit bureaus hold.
Do people act on their concerns?
Many do little, partly because opting out is hard and the benefits are unclear, a gap sometimes called the privacy paradox.
What are the best first steps?
Use unique passwords and two-factor authentication, freeze credit and remove broker listings.
Are the concerns justified?
Yes. Fraud reports, breaches and broker data sales show that personal information is widely exposed.
Sources
- ftc.gov
- ic3.gov
- Spokeo
- PeopleConnect suppression center
- That’s Them
- privacy.ca.gov/drop
- identitytheft.gov
- reportfraud.ftc.gov
- California Privacy Protection Agency
Related Reading
- Privacy and Sharing Attitudes: Key Findings and Practical Tips
- Is Privacy Losing Out to Sharing? What Privacy Attitude Research Shows
- Equifax Data Breach: Millions Still at Risk and What You Should Do Now
- The Worst Year for Data Breaches: 2019 and What Came After
- What Is a Data Breach? Causes, Risks and What To Do
- The Real Cost of Lost Privacy in the Digital Age
- Exposed Online: Why Your Privacy Matters and How to Protect It
- Why Data Privacy Is Important: What Most People Miss
Ready to erase your footprint?
Stop letting data brokers profit from your personal life. Start your removal today.
Start Removing